Why look beyond OneLogin
OneLogin provides a comprehensive suite for identity and access management, including Single Sign-On (SSO), Multi-Factor Authentication (MFA), and identity lifecycle management. It is designed to secure access to cloud applications and streamline user provisioning for enterprises. However, organizations may explore alternatives for several reasons. These can include a need for deeper integration with specific cloud ecosystems, such as those offered by AWS or Azure, which may provide more native identity services tailored to their respective platforms. Some companies prioritize a developer-centric approach with extensive APIs and SDKs for highly customized authentication flows, which might lead them to solutions like Auth0. Others may seek alternatives based on pricing structures, scalability requirements for a rapidly growing user base, or specific compliance and regulatory needs that are better addressed by certain vendors.
Evaluations of identity providers often consider factors like ease of deployment, administrative overhead, end-user experience, and the breadth of pre-built integrations with third-party applications. While OneLogin offers a robust feature set, comparing it against other leaders in the IAM space can help organizations identify a solution that aligns more precisely with their technical architecture, security posture, and budgetary constraints. The market for IAM solutions is dynamic, with various providers specializing in different aspects, from consumer identity (CIAM) to workforce identity, and offering diverse approaches to cloud directory services and access governance.
Top alternatives ranked
-
1. Okta โ Comprehensive identity cloud for workforce and customer use cases
Okta is a widely recognized independent identity provider offering a broad range of services for both workforce identity and customer identity and access management (CIAM). Its platform includes Single Sign-On (SSO), Multi-Factor Authentication (MFA), API access management, and lifecycle management. Okta specializes in integrating with a vast ecosystem of cloud applications, providing pre-built connectors for thousands of services. Developers can utilize Okta's extensive APIs and SDKs to embed identity directly into their applications, supporting custom authentication flows and user experiences. Okta's focus on an open and neutral identity platform allows it to integrate across various cloud providers and on-premises systems, making it a strong contender for organizations with hybrid environments or diverse application portfolios. Its compliance certifications and enterprise-grade security features appeal to large organizations with stringent security requirements. Learn more about Okta's identity solutions.
Best for:
- Large enterprises needing comprehensive workforce and customer identity solutions
- Organizations requiring extensive integrations with cloud applications
- Companies with complex identity governance and administration needs
-
2. Auth0 โ Developer-centric platform for embedding authentication and authorization
Auth0, an Okta company, is a platform focused on making authentication and authorization simple for developers. It provides a highly customizable and extensible identity platform that allows organizations to integrate identity into their applications using APIs, SDKs, and pre-built UI components. Auth0 supports various authentication methods, including social logins, enterprise federations, and passwordless options. Its extensibility is a key feature, allowing developers to customize identity flows using 'Actions' (serverless functions). This flexibility makes Auth0 suitable for applications with unique identity requirements or those needing to support a wide array of user types, from consumers to partners. Auth0's platform is designed for rapid development and deployment, making it attractive to startups and companies prioritizing developer velocity. Explore Auth0's developer identity tools.
Best for:
- Developers building custom applications requiring flexible identity integration
- Startups and scale-ups needing rapid identity solution deployment
- Organizations requiring highly customizable authentication and authorization flows
-
3. Microsoft Entra ID (formerly Azure Active Directory) โ Identity for Microsoft-centric and hybrid environments
Microsoft Entra ID is Microsoft's cloud-based identity and access management service, formerly known as Azure Active Directory. It provides identity services for Microsoft's cloud ecosystem, including Azure, Microsoft 365, and Dynamics 365, and extends to thousands of other SaaS applications. Entra ID is particularly strong for organizations that are heavily invested in Microsoft technologies or operate hybrid environments, seamlessly integrating with on-premises Active Directory deployments. It offers SSO, MFA, conditional access, and identity governance features. For developers, Entra ID provides APIs and SDKs through the Microsoft Graph to integrate identity into custom applications. Its pervasive presence in enterprise IT environments makes it a default choice for many large organizations leveraging Microsoft's cloud services. Discover Microsoft Entra ID capabilities.
Best for:
- Organizations with existing Microsoft infrastructure (Azure, Microsoft 365)
- Hybrid environments requiring integration with on-premises Active Directory
- Enterprises needing robust identity governance and compliance within the Microsoft ecosystem
-
4. Google Cloud Platform Identity Platform โ Identity services within the Google Cloud ecosystem
Google Cloud Platform (GCP) offers a suite of identity and access management services, including Cloud Identity for workforce users and Identity Platform for customer identity (CIAM). Cloud Identity provides centralized user and group management, SSO, and MFA for Google Workspace and other cloud applications. Identity Platform, built on Firebase Authentication, offers flexible, developer-friendly authentication for consumer-facing applications, supporting social logins, email/password, and phone number authentication. These services are deeply integrated into the GCP ecosystem, leveraging Google's global infrastructure and security capabilities. Organizations already using GCP for their infrastructure or applications may find these services provide a cohesive identity solution. Developers can use client and server SDKs to integrate authentication into their web, mobile, and desktop applications. Learn about Google Cloud identity services.
Best for:
- Organizations heavily invested in Google Cloud Platform or Google Workspace
- Developers building applications on GCP requiring integrated identity services
- Consumer-facing applications needing scalable, flexible authentication options
-
5. AWS IAM and Cognito โ Identity and access management for AWS environments
Amazon Web Services (AWS) provides several identity services, primarily AWS Identity and Access Management (IAM) for managing access to AWS resources and Amazon Cognito for customer identity and access management (CIAM). AWS IAM allows granular control over who can access AWS services and resources, managing users, groups, roles, and permissions. Cognito offers user directories, authentication, and authorization for web and mobile applications, supporting social identity providers, SAML, and OIDC. It scales to millions of users and integrates with other AWS services. Organizations building applications entirely within the AWS ecosystem often leverage IAM for workforce identity and Cognito for their customer-facing applications, benefiting from native integration and the broader AWS security framework. AWS provides extensive documentation and SDKs for integrating these services into cloud-native applications. Explore AWS IAM documentation and AWS Cognito developer resources.
Best for:
- Organizations with a significant footprint in the AWS cloud
- Applications needing fine-grained access control to AWS resources
- Developers building consumer or multi-tenant applications within AWS
-
6. Cloudflare Access โ Zero Trust network access for applications
Cloudflare Access is part of Cloudflare's Zero Trust platform, providing secure access to internal applications without a VPN. Instead of relying on network perimeter security, Cloudflare Access verifies every user and device request before granting access to applications, regardless of where they are hosted (on-premise, public cloud, or SaaS). It integrates with existing identity providers like Okta, Azure AD, and Google Workspace, acting as a policy enforcement point. For developers, this means applications can be secured at the edge without modifying application code or deploying agents. It's particularly useful for securing legacy applications or microservices, providing a scalable and performant way to implement Zero Trust principles. Cloudflare Access simplifies secure remote access and reduces the attack surface by hiding applications behind Cloudflare's global network. Read Cloudflare Access developer documentation.
Best for:
- Organizations implementing a Zero Trust security model
- Securing internal applications without a VPN
- Companies with hybrid or multi-cloud application deployments
-
7. Okta Workforce Identity Cloud โ Dedicated for enterprise workforce identity management
Okta Workforce Identity Cloud is a specialized offering from Okta focused exclusively on securing and managing access for employees, contractors, and partners. It encompasses Okta's core features like Single Sign-On (SSO) to thousands of applications, Multi-Factor Authentication (MFA), and adaptive access policies. The platform also includes comprehensive lifecycle management tools for automated user provisioning and de-provisioning, greatly simplifying employee onboarding and offboarding. Okta Workforce Identity Cloud is designed to meet the complex security and compliance requirements of large enterprises, offering advanced reporting, auditing, and integration with HR systems. While Okta's broader platform also addresses CIAM, this specific offering is tailored for organizations whose primary concern is robust and scalable workforce identity management across diverse IT environments. Explore Okta Workforce Identity Cloud features.
Best for:
- Enterprises needing dedicated, scalable workforce identity management
- Organizations focused on streamlining employee lifecycle management
- Companies requiring advanced security and compliance for internal access
Side-by-side
| Feature | OneLogin | Okta | Auth0 | Microsoft Entra ID | GCP Identity Platform | AWS IAM/Cognito | Cloudflare Access |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Primary Focus | Workforce IAM | Workforce & CIAM | Developer-centric CIAM | Microsoft ecosystem IAM | GCP ecosystem IAM/CIAM | AWS ecosystem IAM/CIAM | Zero Trust Network Access |
| Single Sign-On (SSO) | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes (with other services) | Integrates with IDPs |
| Multi-Factor Authentication (MFA) | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Integrates with IDPs |
| Identity Lifecycle Management | Yes | Yes | Yes (Rules/Actions) | Yes | Yes (Cloud Identity) | Yes (IAM) | N/A (focus on access) |
| API/SDK Support | Extensive | Extensive | Extensive | Extensive | Extensive | Extensive | API for policy mgmt |
| Cloud Ecosystem Integration | Vendor-neutral | Vendor-neutral | Vendor-neutral | Microsoft-centric | Google Cloud-centric | AWS-centric | Vendor-neutral |
| Compliance & Certifications | SOC 2, GDPR, HIPAA, ISO 27001 | SOC 2, GDPR, HIPAA, FedRAMP, ISO 27001 | SOC 2, GDPR, HIPAA, ISO 27001 | ISO 27001, SOC 1/2/3, FedRAMP, HIPAA, GDPR | ISO 27001, SOC 1/2/3, HIPAA, GDPR | ISO 27001, SOC 1/2/3, FedRAMP, HIPAA, GDPR | SOC 2, ISO 27001, GDPR |
| Starting Paid Tier (approx.) | $4/user/month | Contact sales | Free to $23/month+ | Free to $6/user/month+ | Free to usage-based | Free to usage-based | Free to $7/user/month+ |
How to pick
Selecting an identity and access management (IAM) solution requires evaluating several factors specific to an organization's needs, existing infrastructure, and strategic goals. Consider the following decision-tree style guidance:
-
Assess your primary use case:
- Workforce Identity: Are you primarily securing employee, contractor, and partner access to internal applications and resources? Solutions like Okta Workforce Identity Cloud or Microsoft Entra ID are strong contenders, offering robust SSO, MFA, and lifecycle management.
- Customer Identity (CIAM): Are you building consumer-facing applications and need flexible, scalable authentication for your users? Auth0, GCP Identity Platform, or Amazon Cognito specialize in developer-friendly CIAM features.
- Zero Trust Network Access (ZTNA): Do you need to secure access to internal applications without a VPN, enforcing granular policies based on user, device, and context? Cloudflare Access is designed for this specific purpose, integrating with existing identity providers.
-
Evaluate your existing cloud ecosystem:
- Microsoft-centric: If your organization heavily uses Microsoft 365, Azure, or on-premises Active Directory, Microsoft Entra ID often provides the most seamless integration and management experience.
- Google Cloud-centric: For organizations building primarily on Google Cloud Platform or using Google Workspace, GCP's Identity Platform and Cloud Identity offer native integration.
- AWS-centric: If your applications and infrastructure are predominantly on AWS, AWS IAM for resource access and Amazon Cognito for customer identities are tightly integrated and optimized for the AWS ecosystem.
- Vendor-neutral/Hybrid: If you have a multi-cloud strategy, a mix of SaaS applications, or a significant on-premises footprint, independent identity providers like Okta or OneLogin offer broad integrations across various platforms.
-
Consider developer experience and customization:
- High Customization/Developer Control: If your team requires extensive control over authentication flows, UI/UX, and integration with custom applications, Auth0 provides a highly flexible platform with powerful APIs and extensibility features.
- Standard Integrations/Ease of Use: For quicker deployment with less custom code, solutions like Okta and OneLogin offer thousands of pre-built integrations with popular SaaS applications.
-
Review security and compliance requirements:
- Ensure the chosen provider meets industry-specific compliance standards (e.g., HIPAA, GDPR, SOC 2) relevant to your organization. All listed alternatives offer various compliance certifications, but specific nuances may exist.
- Evaluate advanced security features such as adaptive MFA, conditional access policies, and threat detection capabilities.
-
Analyze pricing and scalability:
- Compare pricing models, which can range from per-user fees to usage-based billing, considering your projected user growth.
- Assess the solution's ability to scale to your anticipated number of users and authentication requests without performance bottlenecks.